|
|
CITY PLAN COMMISSION
Monday, January 7, 2002 - 4:00 P.M.
PRESENT:
Chairman Mayor Wescott; Lois Feldman; Jeff Zabel; Elbert Rackow; Bud Flood; Fred Steffen; (Excused, Karen Aldinger)
ALSO PRESENT: Comm. Dev. Dir. John Gardner; City Clerk Vicki Zdroik; Mayors Assis. Louis J. Molepske, Jr.; Parks Dir. Tom Schrader; Ald. Molski, Phillips, Moore, Sowieja, Barr, Nealis, Seiser and Sevenich; Amber Maslowski; Melissa Perron; Carl Rasmussen; Rick Rettler; Charles Gust; Paul Witek; Craig Hjelle; J. G. Rosholt; Jeff Murphy; John Clark; Tom Brown; Steve Smith; Tony Patton; Todd Grunwaldt; Reid Rocheleau; Greg Diemer; Cathy Dugan; Barb Martin, Journal; Gene Kemmeter, Po. Co. Gazette
Chairman Wescott noted the latest recorded opening of the toboggan slide is January 14, and with the present 10-day forecast of no appreciable snow, we are one week away from tying that record. Secondly, the developer for the proposal on the Lullabye site will submit his project to WHEDA and will return to the Plan Commission pending a favorable review from WHEDA.
Index of these Minutes:
1. Approval of the December 3, 2001
Plan Commission Minutes
2. UWSP - Align Portage St.
with High St.
3. Preliminary Plat - Heffron
St./Heritage Dr.
4. Conditional Use - Community
First Bank - 5525 Hwy. 10 E.
5. Mid-State Technical College
- 933 Michigan Ave.
A. Conditional Use - Expansion
B. Lease of City Land
6. Expansion of Pfiffner Pioneer
Band Shell.
1. APPROVAL OF THE DECEMBER
3, 2001 PLAN COMMISSION MINUTES
Elbert Rackow moved, seconded by Bud Flood, to approve the minutes of the December 3, 2001 Plan Commission meeting.
Ayes all; Nays none; Motion carried.
2. UWSP - ALIGN PORTAGE ST.
WITH HIGH ST.
Carl Rasmussen, UWSP Facilities Planner, discussed the existing student crossing problems in this area. This area
was suggested for realignment in the 1993 Campus Development Plan. This proposal has been reviewed and endorsed
by the faculty senate and the Student Government Association. The underground steam line is scheduled to begin
in 2003 and we anticipate this project to start in 2004.
Rick Rettler, Rettler Corporation, stated they have worked on this proposal since March. He introduced Melissa
Perron from his firm who is the design technician and did a lot of the design work on this project, and Amber Maslowski
who is in charge of the computer for the presentation. The goals have been to improve pedestrian connection in
the High/Portage Street area as well as to improve traffic circulation. He narrated the slide presentation showing
existing pedestrian traffic patterns and the proposed redesign for Portage and High Streets with improved vehicular
traffic flow and safer pedestrian crossings. Currently, there are no organized crossing points. East-west vehicle
traffic flow will be better than now. There is the opportunity to create public spaces in front of the Learning
Resources Center and the Student Center. These spaces will be used by students as outdoor gathering spaces, something
that is missing now. Details of these spaces need to be completed. A water feature is possible.
John Gardner noted the Police Dept. has indicated they would like no stop signs on the east/west streets. The University
wants stop signs on High and Portage. The details for the actual street paving will have to be selected and approved.
The UW system has expressed an interest in having the city participate in a WDOT enhancement grant. Applications
are due in April and that application would come before the Plan Commission. Final detailed designs will also come
back to the City for review and approval.
Bud Flood noted the plans show future expansion of the University Center and a drive-through canopy.
Carl Rasmussen responded they are looking at that project for 2004-2005.
John Gardner noted the University Center expansion, including the canopy, is not part of this review and would
have to come back for review and approval at a later time.
Jeff Zabel questioned safety issues for students during construction.
Carl Rasmussen responded they construct fences and bridges.
Ald. Barr questioned who pays for construction in city streets.
John Gardner responded it is our intent that the university would pay for this. The hiring of Mr. Rettler is a
city project that is being assessed back to the university through a cooperative agreement. The reason they are
doing this project in connection with the steam pipe project is they have to replace the streets anyway. They may
be asking the city to make an application for a DOT Enhancement Grant. The city would be the applicant and the
university would be a sponsor with us.
Ald. Phillips questioned whether the existing parking will be affected, both in the lot and on the street. What
about fire truck access?
Rick Rettler responded the concept indicates parking lot realignment. For the most part, we have maximized the
parking so we are really not affecting the overall numbers that greatly. If there is any change to on-street spaces,
it will only be a couple.
Lois Feldman moved, seconded by Jeff Zabel, to recommend approval of 1) the realignment of Portage Street and High
Street (not including the student center expansion), and 2) accept the design concept with the understanding that
a detailed design will come back to be reviewed at a later date.
Ayes all; Nays none; Motion carried.
3. PRELIMINARY PLAT - HEFFRON
ST./HERITAGE DR
Chairman Wescott noted the only item before the Commission today is the preliminary plat. This request is subject
to the Boundary Adjustment Agreement with the Town of Plover.
John Gardner stated Mr. Feltz proposes a duplex subdivision based on the 118' wide lots. Gardner was contacted
by an alderperson who felt the westerly row of lots that abut existing single family lots along Lampman Drive should
be zoned single family. He reviewed how duplexes can result in a "row of garage doors" if there are no
design controls. He referenced recommended controls developed by Peter Calthorpe for a project in the St. Croix
Valley. Calthorpe recommended no more than 50% of the facade should be the garage and a garage should be at least
8 feet behind the primary building facade. The city has historically not forced site plan review. Gardner has toured
several duplex areas in the city and Plover and has found only one duplex built to the recommended standards.
Ald. Nealis suggested changing condition #3 to include lots 36-44 for Single Family Zoning and Lots 48-56 for Two
Family Zoning. He felt there needed to be a buffer of single family next to the existing single family before switching
to two family.
Staff recommends approval of the preliminary plat with the following conditions: 1) a fee of $400/lot in lieu of
land dedication, 2) the boundary adjustment attaching this land to the city, 3) "R-3" Two Family zoning,
4) authorize the Mayor to enter into an agreement to have the land subdivided by the private surveyor as shown,
and 5) approve the utility extensions. He noted the Commission may want to address condition #3 with regard to
Two Family Zoning.
Fred Steffen stated if we were to set it up as single family zoning for the lots on the west, Mr. Feltz may want
to have 105' widths for those lots instead of 118'. If we are going to do it, we should let Mr. Feltz know now
so that he can make necessary changes.
Jeff Murphy, representing Mr. Feltz, stated if you want the western lots to be single family, we would modify our
request now to 105' wide lots on the western one-half and 118' wide lots on the eastern one-half. He thinks the
owner would be amenable to Single Family Zoning for his western lots and Two Family Zoning for his eastern lots.
Chuck Gust, 4400 Heritage Dr., noted lots 45, 46, & 47 would be 10' shorter because of the northern 10' to
Woodward Governor. He would like to see Lot 47 reconfigured or used as a neighborhood park for the area because
the 60' street access is too narrow for two driveways.
In response to questions by Ald. Sowieja and Phillips, John Gardner reviewed the park fee standards and the Boundary
Adjustment Agreement with the Town of Plover.
Ald. Nealis suggested future discussions regarding yard lights included in restrictive covenants.
Fred Steffen moved, seconded by Elbert Rackow, to recommend approval of the preliminary plat with Single Family
Zoning and lots approximately 105' wide for the west side of the proposed future street, and Two Family Zoning
with 118' wide lots for the east side of the proposed future street with the following conditions: 1) a fee of
$250 per single family lot and $400 per duplex lot in lieu of land dedication, 2) attach this land to the city,
3) authorize the Mayor to enter into an agreement to have the land subdivided by the private surveyor as shown,
and 5) approve the utility extensions.
Ayes all; Nays none; Motion carried.
4. CONDITIONAL USE - COMMUNITY
FIRST BANK - 5525 HWY 10 E.
Chairman Wescott noted City Engineering and the Council has approved the two driveways. City planning recommends
approval. The site plan meets all requirements.
John Gardner reviewed parking ratios from other communities and noted that ours might be a little high and staff
will bring this issue back in the future. Staff recommends approval.
Bud Flood noted in the future, if we are replacing a building, he would like to see a footprint of the existing
building included.
Elbert Rackow moved, seconded by Fred Steffen, to recommend approval of the conditional use request for Community
First Bank at 5525 Hwy. 10 E. to demolish the existing bank and replace it with a new structure with the condition
that the site plan meet all city requirements including drainage and screening.
Ayes all; Nays none; Motion carried.
5. MID-STATE TECHNICAL COLLEGE
- 933 MICHIGAN AVE.
A. Conditional Use - Expansion
B. Lease of City Land
John Clark, Vice President of Academic Affairs for Mid-State College, stated they have occupied the building since
1961 with an expansion in 1991. He indicated the need for their present request due to expanded course offerings
and a 29% increase in students. We currently partner with, among others, UWSP, Portage County Business Council
Foundation, and Stora Enso. Currently, we are limited by state statutes to a $500,000 building limit without going
to a referendum. Effective in July of 2002, that threshold moves to $1,000,000 that we can invest in facilities
without a referendum vote. The Parks and Recreation Committee has recommended we look at sites outside of the current
location. Our current site is desirable based on location to the university. Given the concerns by the Parks Commission
with regard to green space and parking, we request to table this until the February Plan Commission meeting to
allow us to meet with Parks Director, City Planner, and our architect to develop a plan that would meet the needs
expressed.
Chairman Mayor Wescott moved, seconded by Bud Flood, to table this request until February to allow the opportunity
for Mid State College representatives to work with representatives from the Park and Recreation Committee, appropriate
city and Mid-State staff, and representation from the university. Ayes all; Nays none; Motion carried.
Chairman Wescott noted he would like all alderpersons included in mailings for any of these meetings.
6. EXPANSION OF PFIFFNER
PIONEER BAND SHELL
Chairman Wescott noted this project has been approved for construction in 2002. It has been through the City Council
and the process of room tax allocation. Tom Brown was retained by the Park and Recreation Commission with the total
cost of the project to be $60-80,000.
Tom Brown, architect, reviewed the drawings of the 800 sq. ft. addition which includes storage, bathrooms, dressing
area, office area, and an open lounge. This addition is basically replacing a tent that was used during events.
The gray area indicates where the walls slope down to the ground. Service access would probably be located on the
west side. Disability access would be a ramp on the west and north sides of the addition. The only people using
this addition would be the performers and would not include public access. We are looking at a fiber/cement product
that would look like wood siding but would be impervious to moisture. There have been discussions on leaving out
the interior walls for the first year to see how the area is used. The addition is intended to be a completely
enclosed space to provide security for storage. There will be window area in the doors and a window area for an
air conditioner.
Elbert Rackow moved, seconded by Fred Steffen, to recommend approval of the proposed expansion of Pfiffner Pioneer
Bank Shell as proposed.
Ayes all; Nays none; Motion carried.
Meeting adjourned at 5:30 p.m.
The meeting minutes reproduced on this website are derived from the computer files used to produce the official minutes for the City of Stevens Point, but are unofficial. The minutes on this web site cannot be certified under s. 889.08, Wis. Stats., and cannot be considered prima facie evidence under s. 889.04, Wis. Stats. Certain tables, maps, and other documents that are a part of the official minutes are not included in the files reproduced on this website. Please consult the printed minutes, available in the City Clerk's Office, for the official text. The decisions made by City of Stevens Point boards, committees, and commissions (other than the Police & Fire Commission) are advisory only and are not binding on the city until affirmed at a meeting of the Common Council. Some of the minutes on this web site might not be approved by the Common Council as of today.